Skip to main content
Picked Together
March 13, 2026

Best Fantasy Books for Book Clubs (2026 Picks)

Fantasy books make surprisingly great book club picks — they're packed with themes around power, identity, justice, and belonging that spark rich conversation. The best fantasy books for book clubs combine immersive world-building with emotional depth, giving every member something to connect with and debate.

If your book club has been sticking to literary fiction or contemporary reads, it might be time to step through a portal. Fantasy has never been stronger as a genre for group reading — today's fantasy novels wrestle with colonialism, grief, chosen family, and moral ambiguity just as fiercely as any Booker Prize contender. And let's be honest: it's just more fun when there are dragons involved.

Whether your group is fantasy-obsessed or completely new to the genre, this list has something for everyone. We've focused on books with layered characters, accessible world-building, and themes meaty enough to fuel a two-hour discussion. Ready? Let's dive in.

What's in This Guide

Why Fantasy Works So Well for Book Clubs

One of the biggest misconceptions about fantasy is that it's all escapism and adventure — fun to read alone, but thin on discussion material. The truth is the opposite. Fantasy's remove from everyday reality actually makes it easier to talk about difficult topics. When a fictional empire practices systemic oppression, your group can engage with that topic without it feeling personal or politically charged in the same way a contemporary novel might.

Fantasy also tends to have strong ensemble casts, intricate plots, and big moral questions — all of which give every member of your group something to latch onto. The reader who loves character psychology has plenty to analyze. The reader who loves plot has twists to unpack. The reader who loves themes can connect the fantasy world to our own.

If your group enjoys science fiction, you might find our Best Science Fiction Book Club Picks for 2026 equally useful — many of the same qualities that make great sci-fi discussions apply here.

Top Fantasy Books for Book Clubs

The Fifth Season
N.K. Jemisin
The first book in the Broken Earth trilogy, this novel follows a world where catastrophic geological events periodically end civilization. Jemisin's use of second-person perspective is jarring at first and endlessly discussable once you realize what she's doing with it. The themes of oppression, survival, and environmental collapse are enormous, and every chapter reframes everything you thought you understood. A genuinely unforgettable book club experience — just prepare your group for something structurally bold.
Piranesi
Susanna Clarke
Short, strange, and completely unlike anything else, Piranesi is a mystery wrapped in a fantasy labyrinth. A man lives in an infinite house of halls and statues, and he doesn't know why. The book is a masterclass in unreliable narration and slow revelation, making it perfect for groups who love to theorize. It's also short enough that everyone will actually finish it. If your group enjoys books with narrative tricks, check out our guide to Best Books With Unreliable Narrators for Book Clubs for more like this.
The House in the Cerulean Sea
TJ Klune
A warm, cozy fantasy about a caseworker for magical creatures who is sent to inspect a mysterious orphanage. This one sits at the intersection of fantasy and feel-good fiction — the stakes are real, the themes of acceptance and found family are genuinely moving, and the romance subplot is deeply satisfying. It's ideal for a mixed group where not everyone is a fantasy devotee. Think of it as a gateway fantasy. Groups who love the cozy end of the spectrum should also browse Cozy Books for Book Clubs: 12 Picks Everyone Will Love for companion picks.
A Deadly Education
Naomi Novik
Set in a magical school that actively tries to kill its students, this subversive take on the beloved trope has a brilliant, caustic narrator and sharp commentary on privilege and survival. The protagonist's voice alone will have your group laughing and debating — is she sympathetic? Frustrating? Both? The class dynamics in the Scholomance make for surprisingly rich thematic discussion.
The Priory of the Orange Tree
Samantha Shannon
An epic standalone fantasy — no trilogy commitment required — featuring multiple female protagonists, dragons, and a fully realized world with distinct cultures and religions. It's long, but Shannon keeps the pages turning. This is the pick for book clubs who want to sink into something truly immersive. Themes include political alliance, faith versus reason, queerness, and the cost of legacy. A rewarding, conversation-rich read for groups who aren't afraid of a doorstop.
Jonathan Strange & Mr Norrell
Susanna Clarke
Clarke appears twice on this list for good reason. This 800-page historical fantasy set in Napoleonic England imagines a world where magic has returned — and two very different magicians disagree profoundly on how to use it. The relationship between the two men is a slow-burn study in ego, mentorship, and rivalry. It rewards patient readers and generates endlessly rich discussion about power, obsession, and what we owe each other.
The Poppy War
R.F. Kuang
Dark, brutal, and based on 20th-century Chinese history, this military fantasy follows a war orphan who discovers she has terrifying shamanistic powers. Content warnings are necessary — this book does not flinch from atrocity — but it is one of the most morally serious fantasy novels of the past decade. For book clubs that want to wrestle with difficult questions about war, complicity, and power, The Poppy War is an exceptional choice.
Circe
Madeline Miller
A mythological fantasy retelling that reimagines the witch of Greek mythology as a fully realized, complex woman. Circe is both accessible and thematically rich — power, loneliness, motherhood, and what it means to become yourself are all on the table. It has broad crossover appeal for readers who don't typically gravitate toward fantasy, making it one of the safest choices for a mixed group. Discussion questions essentially write themselves.

Tips for Discussing Fantasy as a Group

Fantasy can feel intimidating to discuss if your group isn't sure where to start. Here are a few approaches that consistently work well:

  • Start with the world-building: Ask members what they found most inventive or confusing about the fictional world. This gets everyone talking quickly and reveals different reading experiences.
  • Connect the fantasy to the real: Fantasy worlds are always reflections of our own. Ask: what real-world systems, histories, or ideas does this world seem to be commenting on?
  • Focus on one character: Big ensemble casts can make it hard to know where to start. Pick one character whose choices were most debated in your group and go deep.
  • Debate the magic system: For books with defined magic rules, what does the magic cost, and who has access to it? Magic systems are almost always metaphors for something.

For ready-made conversation starters, try our Book Club Discussion Questions Generator — it can help you build a tailored question list for whichever fantasy novel your group chooses.

Best Fantasy for Book Clubs New to the Genre

If your group has little to no experience with fantasy, starting with something approachable is key. You want a book with clear stakes, an accessible voice, and themes that resonate even without genre familiarity. Our top recommendations for fantasy newcomers:

  • Circe by Madeline Miller — accessible mythology, literary prose, universal themes
  • Piranesi by Susanna Clarke — short, mysterious, reads almost like a thriller
  • The House in the Cerulean Sea by TJ Klune — warm, gentle, and emotionally resonant

Books that deal with themes of friendship and chosen family — common in fantasy — often land well with mixed groups. For more picks in that vein, see our roundup of Best Books About Friendship for Book Clubs (2026).

One final tip: don't feel pressured to read an entire series as a group. Most of the books on this list are standalones or satisfying series openers that work perfectly on their own. You're not committing to a 10-book journey — you're just choosing a great night's discussion.

Fantasy is one of the most exciting directions a book club can go in 2026. The genre is producing some of the most ambitious, thoughtful fiction being written anywhere, and the best fantasy books for book clubs will leave your group talking long after the wine runs out.

Not sure which fantasy book is the right fit for your specific group? Answer a few quick questions and let us match you with the perfect pick. Take the Book Club Recommendation Quiz →

← Back to Blog